Visual Effects Production Management
VFX production management covers scheduling, assets, progress, vendors, and teams. On large shows, the VFX producer coordinates facilities while each facility manages its artists. On smaller shows, the VFX supervisor may also manage a distributed group of freelancers.
Asset Management
Asset management identifies and names shots, orders plate pulls, organizes media and metadata, and distributes each package to the assigned vendor or artist.
Choose transfer and asset tools around security, bandwidth, file size, and budget. Facilities often use Aspera Faspex, Signiant Media Shuttle, or Sohonet FileRunner. Smaller teams may use Dropbox, Google Drive, or Hightail.
Cloud storage lets production upload once and grant access to multiple artists. This helps teams with limited upstream bandwidth, but does not replace a controlled archive.
Dropbox Business enables granular permissions, allowing production managers to selectively provide artists access to individual plate and render directories on an as-needed basis without granting total access to the production's Dropbox. This provides for higher security and managed control of assets leaving the production. Dropbox also retains file version history and deleted files for a fixed window that depends on the plan: 30 days on personal tiers, 180 days on Essentials/Business/Standard, and 365 days on Business Plus/Advanced/Enterprise, with longer retention available only as a paid add-on.1 Within that window a file that is deleted or overwritten can be restored without significant downtime or re-uploading from an archive. Treat it as a recovery net for recent accidents, not as an archive: a plate overwritten a year ago is gone, which is why the archival copy still has to exist independently.
Many cloud-based file sharing systems include preview and review tools. While visual effects shots are in the creative production phase, a remote artist will upload QuickTime previews to the production's cloud service and the VFX supervisor, director, editor, and other creative executives can review directly in the service's web interface or mobile app and leave creative feedback and notes. This provides for a very fast exchange and review process, often eliminating the need for download and ingest of preview files into a dedicated preview system until it is necessary to perform critical inspection of shots that are presented as potential final versions.
Use Frame.io or cineSync when review requires timecode-accurate annotations and exported notes. See The Creative Review Cycle.
In addition to uploading renders, artists may also exchange working project files and shared assets via the production's cloud service. This can be useful in collaborations between multiple artists that are not co-located, last minute fixes and tweaks if an artist is unavailable, and facilitating distributed rendering of final shots.
Do not assume a post facility will accept a shared cloud folder. Many require direct, secure transfers and prohibit consumer cloud services. Use the facility's Aspera or Signiant server when available. For unrestricted, one-time deliveries, Hightail or WeTransfer may be sufficient.
For large deliveries, it is sometimes faster to copy large files to a physical drive and send it across town the old fashioned way via courier or production assistant. Overnight shipping through UPS and FedEx can even be faster than transferring large files over the internet.
Production Tracking
Track every shot's owner, assets, versions, notes, milestones, approval state, and current DI version. CGI milestones commonly include layout, animation, lighting, and compositing.
Tools like Autodesk Flow Production Tracking (formerly Shotgun, then ShotGrid, and now part of Autodesk Flow) and ftrack (acquired by Backlight in 2022) are industry-specific tools for coordinating visual effects projects. They have key features for asset tracking, deadlines, budgets, shot review, annotation, and client feedback, and serve as central collaborative workspaces that production managers and artists alike can leverage to define and maintain their goals.
These tools are especially appealing to large visual effects studios because of their APIs that allow software engineers and technical directors to integrate the management system directly into their automated pipeline. While heavily customizable, they are also now designed to be accessible and friendly to small productions and studios right out of the box, with software tie-ins to common applications like Flame, Nuke, Maya, Cinema 4D, Adobe Premiere, and more.
Many productions elect to build their own shot and resource tracking databases, often using off-the-shelf tools like FileMaker, Microsoft Excel, or Google Sheets. Depending on the size of the production, the number and complexity of shots, and the number of artists and managers involved, these solutions may be the simplest and most cost effective.
These databases include relevant shot information such as shot name, plate(s), original source metadata, shot description, VFX description, notes, production status, assigned artist/vendor, latest version number, approval/review status, and version currently in the DI edit.
The VFX editor and conform editor reconcile the cut against this database. Keep it current.
VFX production coordinates deliveries between vendors, editorial, and the DI. Send editorial previews to the VFX editor for review in context. Record every note and approval against the exact version.
Review proposed finals in a calibrated environment that represents the target display. Apply the correct CDL, Show LUT, or display transform and play at delivery resolution and frame rate.
If the shot is creatively approved, it will be deemed final and the VFX vendor is asked to deliver a final version to DI pending any technical fixes on their end.
On large shows, send selected WIPs to the DI early enough for grading feedback and contextual review. Each extra version adds I/O, editorial, and grading cost. On a limited budget, deliver one approved final instead of a stream of evolving versions.
After the initial conform, production editorial will follow up with change cuts and/or VFX inserts, providing edit lists of the changes and new shots. Editorial must specify the exact version number of a shot they are cutting in (using the offline QuickTime's clip name) so that the DI has clear instructions that cannot be misinterpreted. It is never appropriate to rely on the DI to guess which version is considered final, as the highest version of a shot is not always the version approved by the filmmakers.
Team Management
Distributed teams need self-sufficient generalists who can complete support tasks, follow the pipeline, and deliver clean work with limited supervision. Do not assume studio experience includes pipeline expertise: provide every artist with explicit color-management, naming, versioning, and delivery requirements.
Work that arrives from outside the shot list
Not every request that reaches a vendor comes from the VFX schedule. Trailer campaigns generate their own shot work, including alternate frame ranges, censored or softened variants, replaced dialogue, and spoiler-free versions. Almost none of it is planned because the campaign develops quickly and mid-cut.
That work is usually funded as an overage against the marketing budget rather than post, so it is rarely a budget crisis. It is a schedule problem. Trailer shots are urgent by definition, artists get pulled off their assignments to service them, and the shots they were working on slip. Plan for the interruption rather than the shot list. See Trailer shots are VFX work nobody scheduled.
-
Dropbox, Version history overview and data retention policy. Dropbox Business did once offer unlimited version history. That changed in early 2017. ↩